December, 2018

Documentary – Motion

, art director at Animat Habitat

This article shares a study of the natural world as represented in documentary film. This study has focused on the message, narrative and perspective of each film, ultimately communicating the plight of the natural world. Each of the following documentaries has an important story to tell, each story has a unique perspective to show, and each film has applied a part of that unique perspective within its story with some success.

This research first considers five documentary films. Two of the documentaries are Netflix originals: Virunga (2014) and The Ivory Game (2016). Another two documentaries: Terra (2015) and Before the Flood (2016) have been licensed to Netflix. Terra is a film by Yann Arthus-Bertrand and Michael Pitiot, narrated by Vanessa Paradis. Before the Flood is a film hosted and produced by Leonardo di Caprio. In fact, three of the first four documentaries in this study were in part produced by di Caprio. In these instances, Leo has acted as a positive influence and Netflix has… The point is that Leo and Netflix are not the headline, here. This preface serves simply as a reflection of today — a day where celebrity thought leaders and video streaming services are who and what people look to for stories. The point is: this is when and where people are.

The last documentary in the first part of this research is Last of the Big Tuskers (2018). Last of the Big Tuskers is a film by James Currie. The film entered festivals in 2018.

Virunga (2014)

1h 40min

Virunga — a Netflix and Grain Media documentary film tells a story of conservation in the context of a war. This first film shares the stakes for park rangers risking their lives to save one of Africa's most precious national parks and its endangered gorillas. In the forested depths of eastern Congo lies Virunga National Park, one of the most bio-diverse places on Earth and home to the planet’s last remaining mountain gorillas.

This is the only region in the world where you can still find mountain gorillas. There are only about 800 left in the whole world. Now if we lose them, we well have lost something very important for humanity. It is thanks to the animals, especially these gorillas, that our forest continues to be protected. Tourism brings in money to help us sustain the conservation of nature. There are many projects being implemented around the park because of the gorillas.” [Translation] — Andre Bauma, gorilla caretaker at the gorilla orphanage in Rumangabo, Virunga southern sector

The narrative in Rumangabo, in particular the story of gorilla caretaker Andre Bauma, is a heartening example of dedication to the endangered gorillas in the circumstance of war. For all the chaos documented in the history of the national park, the heart of the film rests at the gorilla orphanage in Rumangabo. For more about this UNESCO world heritage site and the gorilla orphanage in Rumangabo, see Virunga National Park.

VIRUNGA title

Virunga title lettering © Grain Media

The opening titles for the film strike a visual tone that resonates throughout the score as well as the composition of documentary footage and nature cinematography. The film is scored by Patrick Jonsson, and features an original song “We Will Not Go“ composed by J. Ralph (featuring Salif Keita, Youssou Ndour and Fally Ipupa). The original song serves as a bookend, underscoring the themes in the opening of the film, then repeating over the end credits — recalling the events of the film. The torn and colorful look of the opening titles, designed by Framestore, directly supports the theme of a war-torn history in Congo as well as reflects the vibrant culture and spirit of its subjects: the Congolese. The pattern of colors applied within the title lettering, of course, is the national flag of the Democratic Republic of Congo.

The film, directed by Orlando von Einsiedel, combines investigative journalism and nature documentary in a gripping exposé of the realities of life in the Congo. The film documents corruption and imposition of big oil companies, namely SOCO, as well as other big interests, such as electronics industries, on an otherwise historically undermined but good natured people who have seen some benefit from tourism driven to the park. Despite claiming in June 2014 that they would halt operations, SOCO had refused to withdraw unconditionally from Virunga by the release of the film. [1]

The film is dedicated to the rangers who gave up their lives in the struggle for peace in eastern Congo.

Virunga (documentary film, 2014) is rated 8.2 on IMDB.

VirungaOfficial Trailer (2014).

For more about how to help protect Virunga National Park, see virungamovie.com.

1 Ramsey, S. (2017) “Interview With Emmanuel de Merode, Director of Virunga National Park” National Geographic.

Terra (2015)

1h 38min

Terra — a Hope Production television movie.

In review.

Wild does not mean barbaric. Wild is not contrary to civilization. Wild just means living in nature. Defending what is wild, defending the forest, is a little like defending our natural history, our home.” — Vanessa Paradis, narrator of Terra (2015)

Terra (television movie, 2015) is rated 8.4 on IMDB.

TerraOfficial Trailer (2016).

Before the Flood (2016)

1h 36min

Before the Flood — a National Geographic and RATPAC Entertainment documentary film follows Leonardo di Caprio in the role of United Nations messenger of peace on climate change. Di Caprio documents the forewarned crisis of climate change, and addresses problems and solutions with thought leaders from a range of international industries. When a twenty-something years of age di Caprio had an opportunity to meet then vice-president of the United States: Al Gore, the vice-president took the time to warn:

“This is the most important issue of our time: all our modes of transportation — boats, trains, planes, cars, the way we produce our food, the way we build our cities, almost everything we do releases carbon dioxide (CO2) and that leads to climate change. The polar ice caps will melt. The seas will start to rise. There will be more dangerous weather patterns: floods, droughts, wildfires.”

Leo narrates, “It sounded like some nightmarish science-fiction film, except everything [Gore] said is real and it's happening right now.” The documentary looks at: “how far we have gone, how much damage we have caused, and if there is anything we can do to stop it.” The film serves as a wake up call. In this way, the intent is similar to Virunga (2014): to inform as well as to give hope that action can create change for the better, before it becomes too late.

Before the Flood banner

Before the Flood © National Geographic

Before the Flood (2016) is again similar to Virunga (2014) in the way its narrative conflict vilifies fossil fuel interests: in this case, namely the Koch brothers who have financed an echo chamber of climate change denialism. In an interview in the film, professor of Atmospheric Science at Penn State University, Michael E. Mann brings this corruption into question: “These people are engaged in an effort to lead us astray – in the name of short term fossil fuel profits – so that we end up leaving behind a degraded planet. What could be more immoral than that?” [2]

Before the Flood (2016) is a closer look at the activities, “which drove mankind out of the Garden of Eden.” The film shares a personal story of shifting baselines, relating back to a motif of religious art: The Garden of Earthly Delights (1490-1510) — the modern name given to a triptych oil painting on oak panels painted by Hieronymus Bosch. The triptych is read from left to right, with each panel being essential to the meaning of the whole. The left panel depicts a paradise — a scene in the Garden of Eden. The right panel illustrates a hell — a scene in which humans have succumbed to temptations. The scene is set at night, and the natural beauty that adorned the preceding panels is noticeably absent. This final panel strikes a tone in harsh contrast with the earlier two. The central panel — the panel Bosch called: Human Kind Before the Flood, depicts the expansive garden that gives the triptych its name. Art historians have debated whether the central panel is a moral warning or a panorama of paradise lost. The film shows both are true in the experience of Leonardo di Caprio, and it's happening right now.

In the filming of this documentary, in his role as United Nations messenger of peace on climate change, di Caprio had an opportunity to speak with then president of the United States: Barack Obama. The president reflected on the urgency of climate action and this notion of paradise lost:

“That is the romantic side of it. That is the side that takes a walk with my daughters and I want them to see the same things I saw as I was growing up. Even if you were unsentimental about that, in very hard-headed terms, you have got to worry about the national security of [climate change]. This is why we have to take action now.”

Perhaps the most poignant interview in the film was with former astronaut, and then director of the Earth Sciences division at NASA, GSFC, Piers Sellers. Sellers recounted being up in orbit, “seeing all the cities at night: millions of people all working away, doing something… come around the day side of the world, seeing the world, all the natural systems, the hurricanes: huge great big wheels over the oceans.” Sellers continued, “At the end of all that, [he had become] immensely more fond of the planet.” The interview brings to account personal contribution in the limited time we have on Earth, and Sellers held hope in humanity:

“The facts are crystal clear: the ice is melting, the earth is warming, the sea level is rising. Those are facts. […] This is a problem. Let us be realistic and find our way out of it. And there are ways out it.”

The film concludes with direction on the personal choices that we can all make. Namely, to consume differently. Consider what you buy, what you eat, how you get your power. And vote. Vote for leaders who will manage climate change by ending fossil fuel subsidies, investing in renewables, leaving fossil fuels in the ground, and supporting a price on carbon.

After 21 years of debates and conferences, it is time to declare: no more talk, no more excuses, no more ten-year studies, no more allowing the fossil fuel companies to manipulate and dictate the science and policies that affect our future. The world is now watching.” — Leonardo di Caprio, Paris climate accord signing ceremony, New York City (2016)

It is up to all of us.

Before the Flood (documentary film, 2016) is rated 8.3 on IMDB.

Before the FloodOfficial Trailer (2016).

Take action at beforetheflood.com.

2 Mann, E. M. Website Link

The Ivory Game (2016)

1h 52min

The Ivory Game — a Netflix, Terra Mater Factual Studios and Vulcan Productions documentary film, in association with Malaika Pictures and with Appian Way, tells a story of wildlife crime. The film takes on the perspective of activists around the world on behalf of elephants, in particular African authorities in pursuit of local poaching networks, as well in particular Asian investigators helping to expose the underground legal and illegal market in ivory in China. The film assumes an investigatory style with modern graphics and a modern score, drone footage and undercover footage, nature documentary and tense action surrounding a global criminal network that rivals drug trafficking and human trafficking — a criminal network of wildlife trafficking. Over the past five years, more than 150,000 elephants have been killed for their ivory. With populations in western and central Africa virtually gone, the mass killing is now spreading to east and southern Africa. Criminal networks smuggle the raw ivory into China, where it is carved into luxury items, fueling a multi-billion dollar trade.

This ivory is being moved subversively across continents, being sold under the table. This is black money. It is fueling international crime. This is an international problem. It is not Africa's problem. The individuals that are fighting this battle, they can not win it alone. It is too big. It is too complex.” — Iain Craig, director of conservation at Northern Rangelands Trust, The Ivory Game (2016)

Like Virunga (2016), life-and-death stakes are not far from the surface in a documentary such as this. This film follows the venture of two separate investigatory parties, in particular the Intelligence service in Tanzania, NTSCIU, headed by Elisifa Ngowi as well as the Internet platform dedicated to wildlife crime whistle-blowers, Wild Leaks, headed by Andrea Crosta. Altogether, the two investigations span the story of combating the ivory trade, from the poachers in Africa to the markets in Asia. These ventures serve as the driving force for the film, with a team of people communicating the context alongside the action.

For Andrea and his network, “we want te get as much proof as possible on [top ivory dealers] to show the Chinese government that the illegal trade […] is out of hand, to give them more reasons to close down this evil market.” For people working with Andrea, in particular Chinese activist and investigative journalist Hongxiang Huang, the exposure of a role on this team aims to counter a common narrative for Chinese people and the ivory market in China. Huang says:

“It is very important to the let the world see, there are Chinese trying to fight for elephants, as well — trying to fight back. This could be the turning point of this whole battle for elephants: from now on, China will be part of the solution.”

For Elisifa and the ivory war in Tanzania, “a one man war can never be won,” he says with hope, “but if [he] can convince other persons to join [him] in this fight, for sure we can see the number of these endangered animals growing again to the old numbers, where we had over 100,000 elephants in Tanzania.”

The film shines a spotlight on the achievement of these investigations juxtaposed with ivory stockpiles and human-elephant conflict, interweaving the narratives in China and in Tanzania with nature documentary and the conservation work of Big Life Foundation in Amboseli National Park, Kenya. The film features Big Life Foundation head of security Craig Miller, with co-founder and director of operations Richard Bonham, whose actions carry a third narrative that cuts to the root of the film: the elephants in Africa. Craig and Richard likewise help to communicate the challenges along the way — along with rangers managing the conservation of elephants as well as the livelihood of agricultural communities around the national parks and on the fringe of the wild places.

“Fencing development is the future when you look at Africa. There is no choice involved, it is going to happen, and people of Africa want the same things that everyone else wants. They want to be able to have a TV. They want to have a house, which is not knocked over. The want to be able to store their food in an area where an animal does not get in there and finish it. Internet, which no one really has yet, and without it, these guys are never going to agree to living with wildlife unless they get the best of both worlds.” — Craig Miller, head of security, Big Life Foundation The Ivory Game (2016)

The Ivory Game lockup

The Ivory Game lockup © Vulcan Productions

The original score as well as the graphical overlays underpin the three story lines throughout the documentary. The score features a soundtrack by H. Scott Salinas, which breaks away from an investigative tone and into passages of sweeping orchestral music that pair with the parts of the film nearer to nature documentary. The graphical overlays – also the graphics for the Title Sequence – were created by Kaiserlicht. The opening title sequence references footage of ivory stockpiles exhibited toward the end of the film. The sequence was directed to echo the ivory trade route, visualizing various maps of countries sculpted into the raw ivory tusks. The opening of the film establishes a material context as well as geographical context for the film., which places an emphasis on the global impact of – as well as global responsibility for – the ivory trade.

“Are we really – in our generation – going to allow the biggest mammal on Earth to disappear. Losing elephants from Africa is just a slow erosion of humanity. Then what is next: we are going to lose the rhino, we are going to lose the giraffe, we are going to lose the lion. Suddenly, we are going to have an empty world – full of people – but nothing wild. […] We need to build fences, we need to put in water, and just managing elephants costs money. And, yes, it is a national responsibility but it is actually a global responsibility. The world wants elephants.” — Iain Craig, director of conservation at Northern Rangelands Trust, The Ivory Game (2016)

The film is dedicated to the memory of Satao. The fight continues.

The Ivory Game (documentary film, 2016) is rated 7.9 on IMDB.

The Ivory GameOfficial Trailer (2016).

Join the fight at theivorygame.com.

Last of the Big Tuskers (2018)

59min

Last of the Big Tuskers — an Umboko Productions documentary film looks at the role of dominant elephant bulls in elephant social structures. For a documentary about elephants, the film focuses uniquely less on the matriarchal herds, telling a story of elephant conservation instead in the context of the other elephant groups: askari bachelor herds.

These elephant bulls, called askaris, follow in the footsteps of a patriarch — a biggest bull elephant, likely with the biggest tusks, in the area. The increasingly few elephants with tusks estimated in excess of one-hundred pounds per tusk are known as super-tuskers. This film explains that the tusks of bull elephants grow at an accelerated rate when the bull is coming of age. When an elephant with the genetic makeup for big tusks has just reached the physical maturity of a super-tusker, that elephant becomes a prime target for poaching at the same time as that same elephant has just reached prime age for breeding. In the populations that remain of elephants in the wild, the result is that the genetic makeup for big tusks is artificially devolved.

The ivory trade remains a reality that is impossible to ignore when addressing a future for elephants.

Tusks are more than an indication of social stature for elephants. Elephants need their tusks to survive: to forage, to dig for roots, to dig for water, to strip bark from trees, to topple trees, to defend themselves. Elephant bulls use their tusks in combat for access to females in estrus. The film emphasizes the role of older bull elephants, who become the father figures that young askaris have not had in the matriarchal herd. Old bulls show the ways to water and to survive the challenging landscapes, as well as teach discipline to the young bachelors.

Far too often and for too long, elephants have been poached for their ivory tusks. For the few years leading up to this film, on average, almost one hundred elephants have been killed every day. Every dead elephant is a tragedy for a family-based herd and increasingly for the survival of the highly-intelligent species. The hope for this project is to share the value in keeping elephants alive, in particular big tuskers.

Every now and then, people become evermore desensitized to the ways in which we take advantage of nature, wild or otherwise. This is known as a baseline shift — a baseline that represents what we think of as normal, which changes with every generation. Enter: director and on-camera co-host of Last of the Big Tuskers, James Currie, who grew up in South Africa, and who returns in this film to see the last big tuskers in Tembe Elephant Park.

Last of the Big Tuskers title

Last of the Big Tuskers title © Umboko Productions

Tembe Elephant Park, South Africa, has a unique topography: sandforest. This special sandforest shares a border with Mozambique and holds an elephant population with very special characteristics, as Alois Haberhauer, Elephant Geneticist at the University of Kriel, described in the film: “a special genetic makeup to produce strong tuskers.” Leonard Muller, Elephant Monitor at Ezemvelo KZN Wildlife, also in the film explained the special circumstances for the elephants in Tembe:

“From a genetics standpoint [the elephants in Tembe] are quite gifted, [though this has a lot to do] with the history of the area[,] that this must have been a very difficult area to hunt in the peak of the ivory trade, so that would have left a lot of these bulls alone[.] [The elephants in Tembe] were not hunted back then for their ivory. [As a result, there are] a lot more tuskers [per population size in Tembe] than anywhere in South Africa. Even [compared] to a place like [Tsavo National Park], which is a massive park with lots of elephants, they only have a handful of tuskers [per population size.] [This is] something quite special for Tembe.”

The adventure with James Currie and with co-host in the film, and senior ranger at Tembe Elephant Park, Tom Mahamba travels to Kruger National Park, also in South Africa, then on to Kenya to compare the elephants of other national parks: Amboseli, Chyulu Hills, Tsavo, to the last big tuskers of Tembe. The direction of the film remains centered on challenges facing elephant conservation today, pointing to tourism as a solution: managing the revenue from tourism to support the national parks as well as the communities who continue to co-exist on the front lines of a conflict with elephants. The same elephants that people all over the world – everyone, everywhere – so clearly uphold in story and in art.

“There is mystery behind that masked gray visage and ancient life force, delicate and mighty, awesome and enchanted, commanding the silence ordinarily reserved for mountain peaks, great fires, and the sea.” — Peter Matthiessen, The Tree Where Man Was Born (1972)

The film crowdfunded US$25,000 in a campaign in 2016, and entered festivals in 2018 in the United States as well as in South Africa.

The film is dedicated to the memory of Tom Mahamba.

Last of the Big Tuskers (2018) is not yet rated.

Last of the Big TuskersOfficial Trailer (2018).

Last of the Big Tuskers (2018) is available on Vimeo on Demand.

+


Behind the scenes:

Register for membership behind the scenes of White Elephant.